HR Insights, HR Management

Why Girl Scout Cookie Season is Something I Could Do Without

Photo by Dreamstime

By Laurie Ruettimann

Back in the day, I used to have a real job. I was a Human Resources generalist.

It was my job to be bossy, cranky, and mean. I had a permanent scowl on my face. I was paid a 20 percent bonus if I stopped everyone else from having fun.

There was a woman in my client group who was totally unlike me. She was very social and fun. She planned meet-ups. She coordinated lunches. She hosted Pampered Chef Parties for the ladies in our office — complete with boxes of wine and frozen canapés from Sam’s Club.

Those parties were well attended and rumored to be kind of fun. One time, this employee even invited me to buy Chinese-made kitchen gadgets and cheap, plastic cookware.

Now I don’t begrudge a girl’s night out, and I can always use more ramekins, but this employee used her business e-mail address to send me an invitation.

The “other people” do it defense

I sat on the message for a day because I felt conflicted. On the one hand, I was honored that an employee liked someone in Human Resources enough to send an invite to a party. On the other hand, our company had a no solicitation policy to avoid the peer pressure to donate, pressure to buy boxes and boxes of cookies, and pressure to join unions.

I decided to talk to this employee as a peer. Very casually, I said, “Betty, I really appreciate your invitation. So thoughtful. Thank you. I can’t attend, and you know you can’t send out Pampered Chef e-mail messages.”

Betty was shocked.

She said, “What do you mean I can’t send out those invites? Other people do it.

Great. The ‘other people’ defense.

I explained our company’s non-solicitation policy and said, “Listen, Betty, I’m not mad. The world isn’t going to end. And I need a new pizza stone, so I might buy one from your Pampered Chef catalogue. You can’t send those party invites out to anyone at work. It’s in the handbook. Do you understand what I’m telling you?”

She said, “I was just trying to be your friend, Laurie.”

Right. My friend.

Unfortunately, I was silent for a beat too long and she added, “This is why nobody likes you.”

HR doesn’t want to be the bad guy

Nice. Great. Nobody likes me, but nobody ever likes the HR chick in the office. I am tough enough to stay on point and I reminded the employee that selling anything — popcorn, wrapping paper, magazine subscriptions — violates our non-solicitation policy. And I wasn’t going to buy that pizza stone after all.

Now that Girl Scout Cookie season is upon us, I want TLNT readers to remember three things:

  1. You probably can’t sell your Girl Scout cookies at work;
  2. Your HR department doesn’t want to be the bad guy; and,
  3. I like Thin Mints.

Give me two boxes. Just sell them to me outside of work.

Laurie Ruettimann is an HR professional, speaker, and former blogger on Punk Rock HR. She is also the co-founder of New Media Services, which offers comprehensive virtual, digital, and social media strategies for the career and HR industries. Laurie writes on her blog The Cynical Girl. Contact her at laurie.ruettimann@gmail.com.
  • Arosario

    As a human resources professional and girl scout mom in the 90′s, selling cookies was (almost) an annual ritual. Management only complained when I ran out of Thin Mints & DO-SI-DO’s.

    • http://twitter.com/lruettimann Laurie Ruettimann

      I had employees who put up signs on their cars. “Ask me how to buy Girl Scout cookies. Mobile #….”

      I didn’t even try to fight that battle.

  • http://twitter.com/jkjhr John Jorgensen

    Unfortunately, you can’t pick and choose who can solicit things at work (except United Way…what a racket). Blame the feds.

    • http://twitter.com/lruettimann Laurie Ruettimann

      No I blame George Bush. ;)

  • Diane

    Laurie, I love your blog and find this one of particular use as it provides me with an open and subtle forum to convey to friends and neighbors that if you are trying to sell me sh*t, don’t call it a party. Unless, of course, it’s one of those mom-selling-naughty-toy parties because those are kind of fun.

    • http://twitter.com/lruettimann Laurie Ruettimann

      It’s only a party if I STEAL something. :)

  • Anonymous

    Laurie, I love your blog and find this one of particular use as it provides me with an open and subtle forum to convey to friends and neighbors that if you are trying to sell me sh*t, don’t call it a party. Unless, of course, it’s one of those mom-selling-naughty-toy parties because those are kind of fun.

  • Anonymous

    Sorry I posted twice. Issues.

  • Ryan Kovach

    Why do you hate kittens?

    • http://twitter.com/lruettimann Laurie Ruettimann

      Hahahahahahahaha. I know. I’m an awful person.

  • http://twitter.com/youcanmanage Ed Reynolds

    Bu they are so much easier to DELIVER if you sell most of them at work….and the quantities will earn your daughter all kinds of prizes for most cookie sales!

    • http://twitter.com/lruettimann Laurie Ruettimann

      Yeah. That’s the reason to do it. :)

  • Kendra W

    Ouch on the “This is why nobody likes you”. That was totally inappropriate for that person to say. 

  • Colleen

    My daughter sold cookies and my mom always helped her out by taking an order form to her workplace.  One year they cracked down and told her no.  So my mom put the order form in her drawer and everyone who wanted cookies knew to come place a order “in the drawer”.  I think the other workers – who were pretty unhappy for years – took pleasure in getting their cookies while “sticking it to HR.”  Great sales that year. 

  • Epsgigges

    Can one get fired for selling GS cookies at work?