
By Eric B. Meyer
Last week, we had a two-part series at The Employer Handbook on the interplay between the Family and Medical Leave Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act.
The former clearly obligates employers to afford leave to an eligible employee to care for a sick child. But, what about the latter? That is, must an employer provide leave from work as a reasonable accommodation to an employee to permit her to care for a disabled child?
In a case decided earlier this month (Magnus v. St. Mark United Methodist Church), the Seventh U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago held that the ADA does not require employers to provide reasonable accommodations to non-disabled workers.
Lessons on the ADA from the 7th Circuit
However, that does not mean that employers have carte blanche to discriminate against employees who must care for disabled loved ones. Here are a couple of other lessons from the Seventh Circuit:
- The ADA forbids an employer from discriminating against an employee because of a known disability of an individual with whom the employee is known to have a relationship or association. This is known as associational discrimination.
- An employer may not terminate (or refuse to hire) an employee for unfounded assumptions about the need to care for a disabled person.
- The ADA does not preclude an employer from firing an employee who violates an attendance policy, if the reason for the absence is to care for a disabled loved-one. (Editor’s note: It may violate the FMLA).
This was originally published on Eric B. Meyer’s blog, The Employer Handbook.






















“In MBTI, the letters can't be treated in isolation. The Socionics approach takes MBTI and says it's the cognitive function . . . ”
— David Arceneaux on Coping at Work: When Smart Bosses and Employees Drive Each Other Crazy, 5 hours ago
“And then there's Texas ..... that has said NO to setting up exchanges and is doing every thing possible to . . . ”
— jacque vilet on Four States That Snubbed Health Reform Gaining Jobs From It, 5 hours ago
“Hi Elizabeth - I really think that the whole emerging area of performance improvement is a competency that HR cannot . . . ”
— Carol Anderson on It’s Not Easy, But Here’s Where HR Can Add Value to the Business, 7 hours ago
“Can't disagree with that Sandra, and yes, experts are critical in this complex profession. But if the HR Leader . . . ”
— Carol Anderson on The Model HR Leader? Maybe It’s an Orchestra Conductor, 7 hours ago
“Ha ha. I've become a hugger as I've gotten older, and yes I think it's good to announce yourself once . . . ”
— Crystal Spraggins on My Rules For Hugging at the Office, 8 hours ago